Recently, pop-up ads have once again become a hot topic in Chinese society. A video circulating online shows an elderly person trying to take a photo with his phone, only to be trapped in a continuous loop of advertisements. Each time an ad popped up, the senior tried to exit by tapping the top-right corner, the back button, or the small ‘X’ at the bottom, but the screen kept jumping to new ad pages and even started downloading unknown software. In less than 30 seconds, the phone cycled through nearly 20 different ads. Beyond poor user experience, these intrusive ads can even pose risks to personal safety.
One user reported that while he was driving near a highway ramp during a heavy rainstorm, a slight bump triggered the highly sensitive ‘shake-to-jump’ feature when he was using voice commands to wake up the navigation system. The interface redirected to an e-commerce platform. As he tried to close the ad, he accidentally shifted the steering wheel slightly, nearly causing an accident.
These incidents highlight the core issues with pop-up ads: hidden close buttons, overly sensitive ‘shake-to-jump’ triggers, and sequential redirects.
In April, the State Administration for Market Regulation (SAMR) issued the Notice on Deepening the Governance of the Internet Advertising Ecosystem. This document introduced the concept of ‘internet advertising ecosystem governance’ for the first time and listed the remediation of persistent pop-up ad issues as one of its six key priorities, launching a six-month campaign to restore market order.
In June, the Ministry of Industry and Information Technology (MIIT) held a special meeting targeting non-compliant redirects via information windows (pop-ups) in certain apps during the ‘618’ shopping festival. MIIT mandated that internet platforms and smart device manufacturers immediately conduct self-inspections and implement rectifications. It strictly prohibited the non-compliant display of information windows, warning that violators would face measures such as regulatory interviews, public naming and shaming, and app removal.
In August, MIIT publicly named 26 apps and SDKs for infringing upon user rights, with many cited for issues such as ‘unclose-able information windows’ and ‘erratic redirects upon clicking.’ Meanwhile, the SAMR and other departments continued to advance special campaigns for personal information protection. They cumulatively conducted compliance checks on over 20,000 apps and SDKs, urging more than 4,000 to complete their compliance rectifications.
Despite intensifying regulatory crackdowns, why do pop-up ads remain persistent? The core reason lies in the severe imbalance between the low cost of non-compliance and the massive scale of profits.
Under current regulations, failing to prominently display a close button or ensure one-click closure can result in fines ranging from CNY 5,000 to CNY 30,000 for advertisers, with a maximum penalty of CNY 100,000 for malicious pop-ups. For leading navigation platforms, splash screen ads account for 20% to 30% of their total advertising revenue. In comparison, the fines are merely a drop in the bucket. Once the perception takes hold that ‘non-compliance carries no significant consequences, while compliance yields no benefits,’ industry self-discipline becomes impossible.
Experts and the public have called on the government to improve the mandatory standard system, strengthen law enforcement and supervision, and supplement these efforts with policy incentives, demonstration certifications, and the construction of public technical service platforms.
By Felicity Jin, Researcher